diff --git a/core/src/main/java/me/pikamug/quests/player/BukkitQuester.java b/core/src/main/java/me/pikamug/quests/player/BukkitQuester.java
index 7b72c462a..a759c0cc1 100644
--- a/core/src/main/java/me/pikamug/quests/player/BukkitQuester.java
+++ b/core/src/main/java/me/pikamug/quests/player/BukkitQuester.java
@@ -1345,6 +1345,12 @@ public class BukkitQuester implements Quester {
             if (formatNames) {
                 message = message.replace("<item>", BukkitItemUtil.getName(goal));
             }
+            final String level = BukkitItemUtil.getPrettyPotionLevel(goal.getItemMeta());
+            if (level.isEmpty()) {
+                message = message.replace(" <level>", level);
+            } else {
+                message = message.replace("<level>", level);
+            }
             objectives.add(new BukkitObjective(ObjectiveType.CONSUME_ITEM, message, progress, goal));
         }
         for (int i = 0; i < data.getItemsDelivered().size(); i++) {
@@ -3347,9 +3353,18 @@ public class BukkitQuester implements Quester {
         } else if (type.equals(ObjectiveType.CONSUME_ITEM)) {
             final ItemStack is = ((BukkitStage) getCurrentStage(quest)).getItemsToConsume().get(getCurrentStage(quest)
                     .getItemsToConsume().indexOf(goal));
-            final String message = formatCompletedObjectiveMessage("consumeItem", goal.getAmount());
+            String message = formatCompletedObjectiveMessage("consumeItem", goal.getAmount());
             if (plugin.getConfigSettings().canTranslateNames() && !goal.hasItemMeta()
                     && !goal.getItemMeta().hasDisplayName()) {
+                // Bukkit version is 1.9+
+                if (goal.getType().name().contains("POTION") && plugin.getLocaleManager().hasBasePotionData()) {
+                    final String level = BukkitItemUtil.getPrettyPotionLevel(goal.getItemMeta());
+                    if (level.isEmpty()) {
+                        message = message.replace(" <level>", level);
+                    } else {
+                        message = message.replace("<level>", level);
+                    }
+                }
                 if (!plugin.getLocaleManager().sendMessage(p, message, goal.getType(), goal.getDurability(), null)) {
                     sendMessage(message.replace("<item>", BukkitItemUtil.getName(is)));
                 }
diff --git a/core/src/main/java/me/pikamug/quests/util/BukkitItemUtil.java b/core/src/main/java/me/pikamug/quests/util/BukkitItemUtil.java
index 61726bb31..35410e30d 100644
--- a/core/src/main/java/me/pikamug/quests/util/BukkitItemUtil.java
+++ b/core/src/main/java/me/pikamug/quests/util/BukkitItemUtil.java
@@ -780,11 +780,14 @@ public class BukkitItemUtil {
         if (Material.getMaterial("LINGERING_POTION") == null) {
             return prettyString;
         }
+        if (!(itemMeta instanceof PotionMeta)) {
+            return prettyString;
+        }
         final PotionMeta meta = (PotionMeta) itemMeta;
-        if (meta != null && meta.getBasePotionData().isUpgraded()) {
+        if (meta.getBasePotionData().isUpgraded()) {
             final int level = meta.getBasePotionData().getType().name().contains("SLOWNESS") ? 4 : 2;
             prettyString = ChatColor.GREEN + RomanNumeral.getNumeral(level) + ChatColor.RESET;
-        } else if (meta != null && meta.getBasePotionData().isExtended()) {
+        } else if (meta.getBasePotionData().isExtended()) {
             prettyString = ChatColor.GREEN + "+" + ChatColor.RESET;
         }
         return prettyString;
diff --git a/core/src/main/resources/strings.yml b/core/src/main/resources/strings.yml
index f784c7506..401c8002a 100644
--- a/core/src/main/resources/strings.yml
+++ b/core/src/main/resources/strings.yml
@@ -640,7 +640,7 @@ craftItem: "Craft <item>: <count>"
 smeltItem: "Smelt <item>: <count>"
 enchItem: "Enchant <enchantment> <level> <item>: <count>"
 brewItem: "Brew <item> <level>: <count>"
-consumeItem: "Consume <item>: <count>"
+consumeItem: "Consume <item> <level>: <count>"
 catchFish: "Catch Fish: <count>"
 milkCow: "Milk Cow: <count>"
 kill: "Kill <mob>: <count>"